How to Read Your Roof Insurance Estimate — and Why It Matters
How to Read Your Roof Insurance Estimate — and Why It Matters
When your insurance company sends you a roof damage estimate, it can feel like a foreign language. Pages of line items, depreciation calculations, overhead and profit percentages, and terms like RCV and ACV. Most Texas homeowners accept the first estimate without realizing they may be leaving thousands of dollars on the table. Here is what Shadow Stone wants you to know before you sign anything.
RCV vs. ACV: The Most Important Line on Your Estimate
Every estimate will show either Replacement Cost Value (RCV) or Actual Cash Value (ACV). RCV is the full cost to replace your roof with like materials at today’s prices. ACV is RCV minus depreciation — meaning the older your roof, the less you receive upfront. If you have an RCV policy, you will typically receive the ACV amount first, then the “recoverable depreciation” after the work is completed and invoiced. Understanding how Texas homeowners insurance covers roof damage will help you know which type of policy you have before the estimate arrives.
What Is the Deductible Line?
Your deductible will appear as a subtraction from the total settlement amount. This is your legal obligation — the portion you are required to pay out of pocket. Texas law prohibits contractors from waiving or paying your deductible, so beware of anyone who offers to do so.
What Is Overhead and Profit (O&P)?
Overhead and profit is a line item that covers the general contractor’s cost of managing the project. Insurance companies sometimes exclude or undervalue O&P on initial estimates, particularly on straightforward replacements. Shadow Stone reviews every estimate for missing or undervalued O&P and files supplements when warranted.
Common Items That Get Missed or Undervalued
- Code upgrade requirements — Texas building codes may require additional work beyond simple shingle replacement, such as updated ventilation or ice and water shield. Initial estimates often exclude these.
- Drip edge replacement — frequently omitted from initial estimates despite being required by code during a full replacement
- Pipe boot replacements — often excluded unless specifically documented during the inspection
- Satellite dish reinstallation — a minor item that is frequently missed
- Starter strip shingles — required at eaves and rakes but sometimes absent from estimates
What Is a Supplement?
A supplement is an additional claim filed when the original estimate is incomplete or undervalued. Shadow Stone files supplements regularly on behalf of our customers — it is one of the most valuable services we provide. A supplement does not reopen your claim; it simply asks the insurance company to reconsider specific line items with additional documentation. Read more about how to document hail damage to understand what strong supporting documentation looks like.
Do Not Accept the First Estimate Without Review
Shadow Stone reviews insurance estimates at no charge as part of our inspection service. If we find items that were missed or undervalued, we document and submit the supplement on your behalf. You are not obligated to accept the first number your insurance company provides. Schedule your free inspection and estimate review today.
Call DFW: (682) 224-0041 | Call San Antonio: (210) 236-8919